I have never been to Sanibel Island, but soon, I will not be able to say that. My husband and I are planning a vacation to the island. What are Sanibel Island hotels like? We didn’t book one of the more expensive hotels, but we didn’t make reservations at one of the cheaper hotels either. We chose a mid-priced hotel that offered rooms at an affordable price. I’m sure I will enjoy the trip no matter what the hotel is like, as I don’t need a lot of luxuries, but I hope that the hotel is comfortable.